The ones that got away — Why you should talk with candidates that turned you down and what to ask them

  • It’s not anonymous — You have a ton of context in which to set the feedback. You can spot patterns in the experiences of women and minorities coming through your pipeline.
  • Motivation — People will be more likely to share real feedback when they know your intent is to improve your hiring process and not a Machiavellian attempt to get them to change their mind about your job offer or they’re not worrying about burning bridges with you.
  • Quality — These are the people who were closest to becoming your colleagues, by definition these are the people whose judgment you trust the most. This group experienced the entirety of your hiring process, vs feedback on places like Glassdoor, where they may have only had a first round screening.
  • Batch ’em up — It’s a good idea to batch up this outreach, contacting people 3–4 months after they turned you down. Grouping like this allows for trends to surface, and better perspectives arising from having had time to reflect.
  • Share context — Email the candidates initially, explain that you’d like to chat with them regarding their experiences. Share that since you offered them a role, you trust their opinion and value their feedback. Don’t forget to share your goal — that you’d like to improve your hiring process and lose fewer great candidates like them. A little flattery goes a long way!
  • Entice! — By all means offer an incentive, after all this group of people really don’t owe you anything (a Starbucks card, Amazon voucher, donation to charity in their name). But people often respond well to a sincere request earnestly asked without needing inducements.
  • Prepare! — Look at the offer declines:
  • By diverse candidates, are women and minorities disproportionately represented?
  • By role, did PMs turn you down more than other skill sets?
  • By location, did lots more people in New York turn down offers than elsewhere?
  • Prepare some more! — Before you pick up the phone make sure you review all the notes. You need background. Know the role they were applying for, whether they applied to you or you sourced them, all of the interview feedback, and the reason you think they turned you down.
  • Context — What was the candidate looking for when they started looking at new roles?
  • Branding and messaging — What was their understanding of the role and your company at the outset of the hiring process? Why did they apply or agree to interview? Did that change during the hiring process? Was there anything that confused or surprised them during the process?
  • Experience of hiring process — Did they have a positive experience? Did they feel that your company had a good understanding of their skill set by the end? Which parts of the process particularly gave them that impression? If not, why not? Was there a particular moment in the hiring process where they became more or less excited about the role? Were they interviewing with other companies at the same time? If so what did those other companies do well?
  • Diversity — Were diverse candidates comfortable during the process? Is there any trend or commonality in the experiences of diverse candidates?
  • Competitiveness — Did they have competing offers? How did the opportunity itself compare to their other offers? How did your offer stack up? How was the timeliness of the process? What could have been offered/ done differently that would have resulted in them accepting your role?
  • Their current role — Why did they decide to go with that role/company? What clinched it for them?

--

--

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Jo Avent

Jo Avent

TalentWall Co-Founder. TalentWall is a first-of-its-kind Hiring Management Platform.